Our “Entitlement Society” by the numbers

A common theme you hear from Republican politicians these days is that government’s growing entitlement programs are creating a large permanent class of people willing to live off of government benefits instead of working.

In an Entitlement Society, government provides every citizen the same or similar rewards, regardless of education, effort and willingness to innovate, pioneer or take risk. – Former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney

The good news for us is that there’s data we can use to evaluate those claims, and that’s just what the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities did.  The bad news for Republican politicians is that their claims don’t hold up when you look at the data.

The CBPP looked at the 11 largest federal entitlement programs, which represented 88% of entitlement spending in the 2010 budget — a total of $1.83 trillion.  Included are Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, unemployment insurance, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and the Child Tax Credit, among others.

Here’s how the spending broke down:

53% of entitlement spending went to the persons over the age of 65 (primarily through Social Security and Medicare).  20% went to those under the age of 65 who are disabled, while another 18% went to households where at least one person worked at least 20 hours a week.  3% of the entitlement spending was for unemployment benefits, which require a history of employment in order to be eligible.

Government dependency can only foster passivity and sloth. – Romney

So let’s total it up — 73% of entitlement spending goes to people who we don’t expect to work (the elderly and disabled).  21% of entitlement spending goes to the working poor or people who recently lost employment.  So that leaves just 6% of entitlement spending to people who fall outside those categories.

What sort of spending is in that 6%?  Well, most of that spending is Social Security-related:   survivor benefits for children and spouses of deceased workers and payments to people who elected to retire early between ages 62 and 64.  There’s also some Medicaid expense for the non-working, non-disabled poor.  Those three categories represent two-thirds of that remaining 6%.

In summary, then, you’ve got somewhere between 2% and 6% of entitlement spending that could be being directed at folks who may not really need it — depending on if you want to classify people collecting survivors benefits as passive and sloth-like.  Is this really an “Entitlement Society” or just empty sloganeering?


6 Responses to “Our “Entitlement Society” by the numbers”

  1. One issue is referring to Social Security as an entitlement program with the connotations that the Republicans associate with that term. Workers have been paying into Social Securtiy since its inception, thereby earning those payments. I seem to recall that the federal government has borrowed heavily from the SS fund in years past, contributing to current financial difficulties.

  2. You’re kidding, right? Or did you actually assume that Mitt was talking about those lazy shlubs on Social Security, like my mom? THis has to be the most disingenuous post yet. Point missed, by several miles…

    • The point is that the claim that America is heading down the road to government dependence can’t be made without some proof that it’s happening. Such proof does not exist. There’s no developing underclass here — just people trying to pull themselves up from the recession.

  3. Can you please post a segment called immigration by the numbers, where the number of illegal aliens are compared to the number of Americans who flock to Cancun this time of year. I want to get a liberal perspective on this highly sensitive issue.


  1. It’s Betty White’s Crew that gets the Money « The Daily Pot - March 18, 2012

    […] Our “Entitlement Society” by the numbers (brickcity.wordpress.com) Share this:TwitterFacebookPrintEmailMoreTumblrPinterestDiggLinkedInRedditStumbleUponLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: